Risk & CoverageJane McKinneyJuly 9, 20266 min read
Risk & Coverage Deep Dive

What is Crime Insurance?

Crime insurance is a specialized commercial policy designed to protect businesses from financial losses due to theft, fraud, forgery, and employee dishonesty.

Security lock and business assets protected against theft and fraud
Risk Portfolio Guide

Commercial Crime Insurance Guide

Crime insurance acts as a vital safety net to protect your cash, securities, and property from illegal acts.

Crime insurance is a type of business insurance policy designed to protect companies from financial losses caused by various criminal acts. From owning a small retail shop to running a large corporation, your business is vulnerable to crimes like employee theft, forgery, fraud, and burglary. It is even more critical for companies in high-crime areas or industries that are more prone to theft, such as convenience stores. Without this coverage, recovering from these crimes can cause severe financial strain.

What is Included in a Crime Insurance Policy?

Crime insurance policies are designed to address criminal risks that businesses encounter in their daily operations. It functions as a core component of an organization’s risk management strategy. The scope of this insurance extends to numerous internal threats, such as (e.g., theft or fraud committed within the organization), as well as external threats that impact a business outside its walls. Let’s look at what is typically included in these policies.

Employee Theft
Covers losses when an employee steals money, goods, or sensitive business information. Businesses rely on this coverage against financial damage by internal dishonesty.
Burglary and Robbery
Covers losses from physical break-ins or robberies where money, equipment, or other valuable items are stolen, helping you swiftly recover from theft incidents.
Forgery and Alteration
Protects the business if someone forges company checks, financial documents, or manipulates papers for personal gain.
Theft of Money and Securities
Protects against the loss of cash or securities stolen from your business premises, during transit, or even from a secure storage facility.
Credit Card Fraud
Helps businesses recover lost funds if company credit cards are misused, unauthorized transactions occur, or associated risks arise.
Computer Fraud
Protects against cyber threats and covers financial losses from hacking, phishing, and unauthorized access to your accounts or data systems.
Social Engineering Fraud
Protects businesses from scams where criminals trick employees into transferring money or sharing data (e.g., fake executive emails or phone calls).
Loss of Property Due to Employee Dishonesty
Applies specifically to stolen equipment, physical goods, or corporate assets directly linked to employee theft.
Theft from Outside the Premises
Ensures that assets like cash, securities, or equipment are protected when they are outside your primary business location (e.g., during transit to a bank).
Funds Transfer Fraud
Protects against financial losses resulting from unauthorized money transfers from your business bank accounts due to hacking or fraud.

What is Not Covered Under Crime Insurance?

While crime insurance is broad, certain exclusions apply. Knowing what is excluded helps you patch potential gaps with other policies:

  • Employee Theft by Owners: Acts committed by you, partners, or directors are excluded.
  • Theft of Personal Property: Employees' or customers' personal property is not covered.
  • Damage to Property: Physical damage to your building (requires Property Insurance).
  • Losses from Unlawful Activities: Criminal acts committed by the business entity itself are excluded.
  • Losses from Vendors or Third-Party Fraud (unless covered by specific ).
  • Losses Due to War or Terrorism: Standard exclusion across all .
  • Cybercrime Data Breaches: Ransomware data restoration or notification costs (requires Cyber Liability).
  • Loss of Funds Due to Poor Business Decisions: Bad investments or business transactions.
  • Theft Not Reported Timely: Failures to report within the specified policy timeframe.
  • Indirect Financial Losses: Lost potential income due to business disruption.
Watch: Understanding Commercial Crime Insurance and why standard property policies leave gaps.

Crime Insurance vs. Fidelity Bonds

Many business owners confuse Commercial Crime Insurance with . While both address theft and dishonesty, their applications differ:

FeaturesCommercial Crime InsuranceFidelity Bond / Surety Bond
Employee Dishonesty Coverage
External Theft (Burglary/Robbery)
Social Engineering & Computer Fraud
Required for Client Contracts (Third-Party)Optional RiderTypical Purpose
Protects Business Assets DirectlyIndirectly (Guarantees Payment)
Structured as Insurance PolicyThree-party contract agreement

How Much Does Crime Insurance Cost?

The cost of crime insurance varies based on the size of your business, industry, location, and the coverage limits you choose. Small businesses with basic coverage typically pay between $650 and $2,500 annually. Premiums may be higher for larger firms or those in high-risk industries like retail or financial services.

$650 - $2,500
Small Business Range
Average Annual Cost
$50,000+
Minimum Base
Typical Coverage Limit
30+
Underwriting Partners
A-Rated Carriers Shop

Estimates based on national averages for small to mid-sized retail and service businesses.

Who Needs Crime Insurance?

Crime insurance is for all businesses that are at risk of both internal and external theft, fraud, and cybercrime. It provides an essential safety net, mitigating financial losses so owners can focus on what is important. Retail, finance, and hospitality industries are highly exposed to these risks. However, the need for crime insurance extends to any business that deals with cash, sensitive information, or valuable assets.

  1. Retail Store Owners managing significant cash transactions and inventory.
  2. Restaurants and Food Service Businesses handling physical cash registers and employee shifts.
  3. Manufacturers with valuable raw materials or inventory vulnerable to theft.
  4. Franchise Owners maintaining standard security controls across multiple sites.
  5. Hospitality Businesses (Hotels, Motels) managing customer transactions and premises access.
  6. Real Estate Agents and Brokers managing trust accounts or .
  7. Healthcare Providers handling billing systems and sensitive patient details.
  8. Construction Companies keeping tools, equipment, and building materials on job sites.
  9. Technology and Data Companies protecting expensive hardware and digital systems.
  10. E-commerce Businesses with physical storage locations or shipping hubs.
  11. Non-Profit Organizations managing donor funds and public accounts.
  12. Transportation and Logistics Companies moving assets and valuable cargo.

Pros

  • Protects cash, checks, and securities which are usually excluded in property insurance.
  • Offers coverage against sophisticated social engineering and computer hacking fraud.
  • Replaces stolen goods or equipment caused by dishonest employees.

Cons

  • Does not cover losses from owners, partners, or major stakeholders.
  • Requires clear, documented proof of theft/dishonesty to pay out claims.

How to Get Crime Insurance in 3 Easy Steps

Getting protected is fast and simple. Insure C-Store matches your business risk profile with top carriers to find optimal coverage. Get started online today.

01

Provide Business Details

Enter your business ZIP code, employee size, and annual revenue in our secure quote tool.

02

Compare Tailored Quotes

Review matched policies from 30+ top commercial carriers to find the coverage limits that match your risk.

03

Bind & Access Certificates

Make a secure payment, activate your crime coverage, and download your Certificate of Insurance (COI) immediately.

Power of Choice
Compare 30+ A-Rated National Carriers
AmTrust logo
Chubb logo
Liberty-Mutual logo
Nationwide logo
Progressive logo
Zurich logo
Travelers logo
The-Hartford logo

Regional Underwriting Availability

Click on highlighted states below to view local policy options:


Frequently Asked Crime Insurance Questions

The two main forms of crime insurance are employee dishonesty coverage, which covers theft or fraud by employees, and commercial crime coverage, which protects against external threats like burglary, forgery, and cyber fraud.

Fidelity insurance (or fidelity bonds) is a specific type of crime coverage that primarily addresses employee dishonesty. Crime insurance is a broader policy that covers external crimes like burglary and fraud alongside employee dishonesty.

The amount depends on your business size, cash levels, inventory value, and transaction volume. Experts recommend coverage that equals or exceeds your potential maximum cash or inventory loss on any given day.

No. A crime bond is a surety bond that guarantees compensation to a third party if a crime is committed. Crime insurance is a direct first-party policy that reimburses your business for its own crime losses.

According to industry research, employee theft costs US businesses an estimated $50 billion annually 1, with convenience stores and retail outlets facing higher burglary rates 2. Standard cyber security tools block many external attacks, but social engineering scams remain highly successful 3.

Sources & Citations
  1. [1]National Retail Federation (NRF) Security and Theft Report, 2025.
  2. [2]Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Uniform Crime Reporting Program.
  3. [3]Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) Social Engineering Trends.
Written by
Jane McKinney
Senior Commercial Broker, McKinney & Co

Jane McKinney is a commercial insurance veteran with over 15 years of experience advising convenience store, gas station, and retail franchise owners across the country.

Protect Your Cash and Property Today

Compare crime insurance rates from 30+ top carriers. Simple online quotes in under 5 minutes.

Start My Quote